Tag archives for critique

Problems with Gamification

Edward Castronova on the blog Terra Nova recently posted his thoughts on gamification.  Interestingly, he talks about how his gamified syllabi in classes have bombed and that he has mixed feelings regarding gamification.  He explains that students don’t want their grades determined by MMORPG mechanics.  He cites a number of challenges with gamifying classrooms: time [...]

Read the rest of this entry »

Ian Schreiber’s Problem with Gamification

Game designer Ian Schreiber writes a blog post entitled My Problem With Gamification.  In the post, he describes three main points that people are making regarding gamification: “(1) The education system in the US is broken. (2) Grades are an outdated game mechanic. This is part of the problem. (3) Replacing grades with other extrinsic [...]

Read the rest of this entry »